I stood there for some brief time, transfixed by the idea, the intimacy of the moment, and the danger of losing myself, my identity, to her. John Homan, the duped husband, stood by Hilley, moving to an Anniston hotel to be near her during the trial. While she was out on bail, she had been staying at a hotel in Birmingham, Alabama. Unknown to Frank, his wife frequently engaged in sex with her bosses in exchange for money or superior performance evaluations. They fall in love and begin living together. Within a few months, Carol began experiencing trouble with nausea and was admitted to the emergency room several times. Unfortunately,themother and daughter werent muchalike,and their relationship suffered as a result. The following day, Carol was admitted to the University of Alabama Hospital. Thats not her sister.. For Carol Hilley, the daughter she tried to poison, the answers arent as straightforward. Gary Carroll said police would bug Hilleys phones and she wouldnt receive the threatening calls that she claimed took place constantly. She was taken to the hospital for a checkup, and just like with her father, the doctors werent sure what was going on with her. (Stephen Gross/ASSOCIATED PRESS) But that was not the end of her story. Today, shed much rather talk about her other family members her brother, his wife, kids and now grandchildren than about her mother. Set the time and location or opt to make it an online event. I remember talking to a bunch of women up there who said, We just didnt buy that, Carroll said about his investigation in Vermont and New Hampshire. 2d 65 (1983). And thats when Carol also started feeling deathly sick. Every time someone calls to ask me about it, I say, Surely this will be the last time, Carroll said. Genre Pop-Culture Insights and Interviews from David Weiner, Nostalgia Curator. You have permission to edit this article. But the bizarre story didnt end there. Audrey then started to inject Carol with what she claimed was for nausea. What Role Did Sheila LaBarre Play in Kenneth Counties Disappearance? Find 8 people named Carol Hilley along with free Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, and TikTok profiles on PeekYou - true people search. There, she faked a kidnapping, stole her uncle and aunts car, and took off. - Listen to Case 236: Sophie Lionnet by Casefile True Crime instantly on your tablet, phone or browser - no downloads needed. They eventually moved to a new home in a good neighborhood. Frank died in 1975 after hed been married to Marie for 25 years. Upon their return to Anniston, Marie and Carol moved in first with Frank's sister Freeda, then with his mother Carrie Hilley. By the time she escaped prison in 1987,her luck ran out altogether. Prosecutor in Brandon Duran Case Discusses In-Depth Details, Brandon Durans Mother Looks Back on His Life, More and More Evil Revealed in Brandon Duran Murder, Police Sergeant Looks Back on Details of Sheila LaBarre Case. He died just over a. Marie got a job at Dresser Industries and also worked nights for Harold Dillard, the owner of a local construction company. Tune in to find out why arsenic is surprisingly present in the food we eat, and why you should never trust your mother in law's coffee. Investigators Look Back on the Frank Arroyo Case, Frank Arroyos Daughter Reveals He Knew Death Was Coming, Frank Arroyos Girlfriend and Daughter Home During His Murder, Many Suspects Unravel in Frank Arroyo Murder, Kathryn Sinkevitch Convicted Guilty and Sentenced to Natural Life, Significant Information Revealed in Kathryn Sinkevitch Case, Michael Agerters Mother Looks Back on His Life, Multiple 911 Calls Made After Shots Fired at Michael Agerter, Aria Armsteads Friend Believes She Was Mentally a Child, Lee County Sheriffs Sergeant Speaks Out on the Matthew Collins Case, Matthew Collins Girlfriend Filed Missing Persons Report, A First Look at the Disappearance of Matthew Collins, Marie Witte Case Was this Detective's "Most Memorable Case", Marie Wittes Half-Sister Discusses Their Childhood, Paul Wittes Half-Sister Gives Her Side of the Story, The Details in Paul Wittes Death Alarm Investigators, Detectives on Purdie Clark Case: "She Was Evil". She has also been indicted for check fraud. Homans devotion to his wife led him to relocate to Anniston during her trial, where he lived the rest of his life, even after her death. He suffers from stomach pains for months while Marie Hilley cares for him. She frequently talked about her imaginary twin sister "Teri", who supposedly lived in Texas. We were getting ready for a shift change and I got a call about a vicious woman.. On February 19, 1987, authorities made the mistake of granting Marie a furlough from Tutwiler prison in Wetumpka. "They kept saying that it was in my head," Carol said. She soon blew through that money and about three years later, Audrey took out a $25,000 life insurance policy on her daughter, Carol; with an additional $25,000 accidental death rider. Now, Teri went to meet John and moved in with him, but they didnt marry. John was a decent guy, but I dont think he was the kind of guy women wanted to spend all winter with, Carroll said. Despite Frank's well-paying job and Marie's secretarial employment, the couple had little money set . She was 53 years old. Years ago, it was said that Carol Hilley was living with a domestic, female partner. Create your free profile and get access to exclusive content. Carol Hilley, the daughter of Frank and Marie Hilley, reflects on her father's passing and problems with her mother. After that, Carol Hilley would not be completely well again for a long, long time. When Frank had been sick, Mariehad volunteered to give him injections of medicine, whicharousedsomesuspicion. PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK. Killed her first husband, Frank, with poison, then attempted to kill her daughter, Carol, the same way, both for insurance money. Just like when she was growing up, after Audrey Marie Hilleys arrest in 1983, Carol said she never bothered to get the truth out of her mother. Some in the Hilley family thought Carols symptoms were eerilysimilar tothose that killed her father. Audrey was already under investigation and arrested for issuing bad checks. Listen to this episode from Casefile True Crime on Spotify. Detectives learned that Marie had recently taken out a $25,000 life insurance policy out onCarol, which designated her as the beneficiary, according tocourt documents. Over the summer she grew sicker and weaker. When Hilley was finally caught in 1983, Carroll said a change of identity didnt come as a shock. Suspicious,they contacted police, who began looking into the puzzling case. On this Wikipedia the language links are at the top of the page across from the article title. Carroll said he got a taste of what was to come when transporting Hilley from Vermont to Atlanta, when he and FBI agents had to sprint through a sea of photographers at the airport to catch their plane. A fugitive from the law, she resumed a normal life, living with her husband and taking up work at a manufacturing plant. Previously city included Anniston AL. Marie Hilley, Frank Hilley: Alabamas Wife, Mother, Murderer True-Story Movie Revisited. What Was the Cause of James Bud Phillips Erratic Death? In 1975, after returning home early due to his illness, Frank found Marie in bed with her boss. This episode has been added to the Casefile Spreadsheet. 1979:Carol Hilley presents with strange symptoms, such as numbness, nausea, and abdominal pains. Carroll said that was par for the course in Hilleys made-up life. Despite a life insurance payout, her debts keep piling up as the same illness threatens to kill her daughter as well. When Mothers Day came up not long after the trial, Carol said she remembered shopping for a card with her brother, when they realized nothing quite summed up their feelings. Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window), Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window). Please note: Starting with Case 200, we are using a new Casefile Ratings Form (200-). Audrey Marie Hilley was an American murderer. James Kohnles Son Reveals the Effects of His Fathers Death, Firefighters Recall Finding James Kohnle in Burning Home. There were several policies, including fire insurance, cancer coverage, and life insurance coverage on herself. Subsequently, investigators found that both her mother and her mother-in-law, Carrie Hilley, had significant, but not fatal, traces of arsenic in their systems when they died. She died of exposure in 1987 at the age of 53 while on the lam from authorities. But years later, his daughter going through the same symptoms aroused suspicion, with the roads leading to Audrey Marie Hilley, Franks wife. He died just over a week later. Now retired, Carroll said hes getting ready to once again talk about the Hilley case with the Discovery Channel for an upcoming program. Late in the summer of 1982, she left New Hampshire, telling her husband that she needed to attend to family business and to see some doctors about an illness. Soon, the FBI investigated. She was indicted in 1979 for the attempted murder of Carol but escaped while free on $14,000 bond. But she was still feisty, and although she was becoming increasingly dependent on Marie's care, she insisted on moving into her own apartment. Notifications from this discussion will be disabled. Perpetrator of one of the most bizarre and convoluted murder cases of all time. He wasn't ready to leave his wife quite yet, though. Don't knowingly lie about anyone Arrested. racist or sexually-oriented language. It was clear to me he had been completely deceived by her.. By now another charge had been added the murder of Frank Hilley and Marie's bond was set at $320,000. Thats when she took out life insurance on Carol. If you have already listened to the episode, you can submit your rating at the Casefile Ratings Form. He died just over a week later. Nee: Frazier Born: 4 June 1933 Died: 26 February 1987 Active: 1975 to 1979 Location: United States of America . Her real name is Thandiwe Newton. You can watch the episode, Alabama Murder Mystery, onAmerican Monsterat IDs website. Carol remembers getting sick just a few years after his father died, and she had trouble seeing and controlling her body movements. She returned a few months later, thinner, with a stylish new blonde haircut, and a different personality one she said belonged to Teri Martin, Robbis sister. Billy Lett said even though his memory isnt what it used to be, he still recalls the details of a routine shift 25 years ago on Feb. 26, 1987. Where is Carol Hilley Now? Best Match Powered by Whitepages Premium AGE Carol Marie Hilley Jacksonville, AL View Full Report Addresses School Cutoff # X, Jacksonville, AL School Cutoff, Jacksonville, AL She was a lady that liked to spend a lot of money. But $25,000 doesnt seem like a lot of money.. Was Justice Served in the Irenia Cotner Case? The woman who found Hilley described her appearance as scary, stating she was dirty with mud on her face and long fingernails. Another identity? The true-story crime family drama aired for years on Lifetime and Lifetime Movie Network (LMN). Inside a box in the cellar, she found a pill bottle and brought it to police, who testeditand found it contained arsenic, according to Snapped.. She was suspected, however, in the deaths of others who died in her care. Her final cause of death was attributed to hypothermia and exposure. She received a life sentence for the murderof Frankand an additional20-yearsentence for the attempted murder ofCarol,according to theAssociated Press. Michaelcontactedthehospital staff,who said they never authorizedMarietogive his sister injections. The only problem was, that facility didnt exist. It was a waste of time to get her to tell the truth.. In August 1982, she said she was going to Texas to visit some relatives. Soon, the couple had two kids Mike and Carol. The night's festivities included the usual young adult diversionsfood, drink, a little marijuanaand as the party wore on Carol became nauseated. Oh wow! On the weekends, the Hilley family often attended backyard barbecues and country cookouts. While a note was left behind indicating that she "might have been kidnapped," Marie was listed as a fugitive. June 8, 1983: Carol Hilley recuperates, and Marie Hilley is finally convicted. Frank Hilley dies on May 25, 1975. November 1979: Marie Hilley bonds out of jail and then vanishes from a Birmingham hotel. Audrey Marie Frazier was born on June 4, 1933 in the Blue Mountain area of Anniston, Alabama to Lucille (ne Meads) and Huey Frazier. RSVP to your 1976 class reunion or schedule one with your fellow alumni. When residents of the affluent Southfields area of south-west London notice foul smelling smoke coming from a home on Wimbledon Park Drive in September 2017, firefighters arrive to make sure the house. Carol remembers getting sick just a few years after his father died, and she had trouble seeing and controlling her body movements. Hilley left Marlow in 1982, telling Homan she needed to visit her twin sister in Texas. She promptly was extradited to Alabama to stand trial. We found 76 records for Carol Hilley in Jacksonville, Boaz and 12 other cities in Alabama. The headline below: "Mrs. Hilley in Calhoun jail". Wilshire Court Productions produced the movie and filmed it in Atlanta, Georgia. During this time she travelled to Texas and Florida, using the alias Teri Martin. His medical doctor never pinpoints what is wrong. Marie Hilley continues giving her daughter the deadly injections. Subscribers can sign up to receive our weekend e-edition on Saturday at 6 a.m. via email. She said it was cloudy and white-looking stuff. In an interview, Carol stated that she didnt get along with Audrey back then. Forensic tests on samples of her hair were conducted by the Alabama Department of Forensic Sciences on October 3, 1979, revealing arsenic levels ranging from over 100 times the normal level close to the scalp to zero times the normal level at the end of the hair shaft. Billy Lett said even though his memory isn't what it used to be, he still recalls the details of a routine shift 25 years ago on Feb. 26, 1987. While being interrogated by Vermont state troopers, she confessed that she was wanted in Alabama on bad check charges and her true name was Audrey Marie Hilley. This time no one stepped forward to pay it. Marie was incarcerated on her bad check charges when she was arrested on October 9 for the attempted murder of her daughter. She told authorities her true identity and that she was wanted for writing bad checks in Alabama. Rate. Gibson was one of the many neighborhood children who had fallen ill after drinking beverages that they had been given during visits to the Hilley household. Carroll said he was the last person Hilley ever saw. Hilley, 53, had failed to return after being furloughed Sunday from a prison near Wetumpka. Keep it Clean. During the trip, using the alias Teri Martin, she called John Homan and informed him that Robbi Homan had died in Texas but there was no need for him to come to Texas because the body had been donated to medical science. Meanwhile, Marie had been buying insurance. 1981:Robbie, aka Marie Hilley, marries a gullible man named John Homan. On returning home she discovered that her grandmother, Carrie Hilley, was in the hospital after fainting at church. I didnt believe anything that came out of her mouth. Carol left church services early and vomited in the parking lot. How Did the Sheila LaBarre Murders Affect Her Community? By using the site, you consent to these cookies. Do Investigators Believe Barbara Holder's Story? Despitethe evidence, Johnstood by Marie and continued to support herallthroughout the trial. Although police and the FBI launched a massive manhunt, Marie Hilley remained a fugitive for a little more than three years. On the day she was supposed to return to jail, she said she was going to visit her mothers grave. She told Robertson that she had cancer and couldn't afford the treatments she needed. May 19, 1975: Frank Hilley arrives at UAB with nausea and pain in his abdomen. The car was found in Marietta, Ga., but Hilley had fled to Fort Lauderdale, where she assumed the name Robbi Hannon. After her father died, Carol said, any sense of normalcy went out the window. He died in 1989. Facebook gives people the power to. Get an all-access pass to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more! Carol Hilley lives in Jacksonville, AL; previous city include Anniston AL. First,shemurdered her husband andalmost got away with it untilshetried to kill herdaughter. Get started for free todayFor all credits and sources please visit . Hilley was conscious at the scene but had convulsions and lost consciousness while being transported to a nearby hospital for treatment. But Marie also insured the lives of her childrenMike was insured for $25,000, while Carol, through two policies, was insured for $39,000. The following day, though, the nausea returned with a vengeance. She had been brought up by parents who both worked long hours and they saw new clothes, toys and other niceties as a suitable replacement for hugs and . I sometimes think how my mother cheated my father out of his grandchildren, Carol said. Investigation Discoverys American Monster: Alabama Murder Mystery delves into a story that had numerous twists. An obituary appears in the paper for Robbi Homan, which raises detectives suspicions. She lied about everything, Carol said. Sheevenvisited the company where Robbi had worked, telling hermanager andco-workers thatRobbihad died. Frank Hilley dies on May 25, 1975. Marie wanted to live a fantasy lifestyle, he said. From the time she was 17 until her mothers arrest when she was 19, Carol said Audrey would come and go from their home in Anniston, hardly ever telling anyone where she was going or why. Soon after, his wife Marie Hilley began to receive threatening phone calls, messages and damage to her property. We found 15 records for Carol Hilley in AL, TX and 9 other states. It was clear to her family and police that Hilley was in debt from trying to live an extravagant lifestyle she couldnt afford on her modest secretarys salary. For the most part, though, her life growing up in Anniston the daughter of Audrey Marie Hilley is a faded, distant memory. She was muddy and soaking wet, Carroll said. Who Was the Mastermind in Frank Arroyos Murder? But a few years later, investigators would learn that there was foul play involved in Franks death. Shes bleeding, shes bruised, her clothing is torn from her body, Manis told Snapped.. Frank was the son of Clarence and Carrie Hilley. In May 1975, 45-year-old Frank Hilley began experiencing severe nausea, vomiting and stomach cramps in his home in Anniston, Alabama. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Exposure to severe cold and rain for four days meant that she had difficulty maintaining her body temperature. TM & 2015 Turner Entertainment Networks, Inc. A Time Warner Company. Read More: How Did Brian Klinefelter Die? Create a password that only you will remember. They took him on to the hospital,and within a day or two,he was dead.. In February 1987, she was given a three-day pass to visit her husband John Homan, who had moved to Anniston, Alabama to be closer to his wife. Several months later, John received a phone call from Martin, saying his wife had died and that her body had been donated to science. Panicking, Marie had Carol discharged from the hospital that afternoon. Carol Hilley was on borrowed time when a seemingly innocuous event saved her life - and changed Marie's forever. Link your TV provider to stream full episodes and live TV. Carroll said Hilley was probably following the train tracks after she left John on her furlough, but has no idea where, if anywhere, Hilley planned to escape to. Sometime in 1975, Frank started to suffer from an illness where he constantly complained of nausea and abdominal pain. Oxygen Insider is your all-access pass to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more. She would always tell us she was having crimes committed against her, Carroll said. She initially spent time with Homan but one day left him a note and fled. A photo of her surfaced on Facebook some years ago. Just something wasnt right about her, Carol said, recalling how her mother would make up extravagant lies for seemingly no reason. Join Facebook to connect with Carol Hilley and others you may know.