Though I did see the charm the actor brought to the role that was a little too fan-servicey for me. It was just the two of them, but in this ending, there were several others. I Think the drama ended in happy ending. That said, I've never had a brain tumor killing me. I'm probably more content with the ending than I should be but drama I love you so much <3 So I finally understand why Young committed suicide last episode, with faith that Soo would save her from death. As Leaphorn, Chee, and Manuelito converged on the thieves' cave, they. This is one drama that defies logic. i can't believe that is finished now.best best drama i have ever seem and it's the best drama of 2013. Plot Summary In 2001, best-selling American author Annie Gallagher loses her beloved Irish grandfather Eoin to cancer. Boss Man turns over Soos cards, revealing that Soo did have a flush, and thus the winning hand. Yes, the picture at the end was pretty. Since everyone went all in, he won the game, and all of Boss Mans money. Enemy is a film that's expertly subdued by both Villeneuve's direction and Gyllenhaal's duality in his performances. But how? There are some other very real plot developments that will help to further interpret the film's ending. Youngs eyes begin to fill with tears as Soo pours his heart out in the video, saying how much he wanted to tell her when he first fell in love with her and how beautiful she was, and how much her real brother loved her. Which brings another question: what happened then to the money OS won (since he left it there and he was knifed/left for dead later)? What the Wind Knows grants a shift in perspective, allowing readers to realize what is important has always been important. I will agree with deducing opera, that in general, barring sacrificing yourself in a suicide 'mission' to save others, suicide is a big o' hey look at me. Well done. That scene jump from cafe to that path lined with cherry blossom trees was so abrupt and strange, kind of like how it would happen in dreams. , Print length . :3, Anyway, if that isn't enough to convince you, in an interview with Song Hye Gyo, she confirmed that it was a happy ending and both characters were alive. ", Throughout the movie, we've heard Emma repeating the names of the demons mentioned in the pamphlet, and toward the end, we even get a look at it. This right here. Spellbinding..Enchanting.Transporting !! Sometimes you can't explain your heart. Well , some missing point that we need to understand OY is not only blind but psychologically is not stable. Link's Awakening ends by showing all of the people who helped along the way, and how they are literally ceasing to exist because they were all a dream. But I'm leaning toward a happy-ever-after both are alive and living and loving ending, because hey, this is K-drama land, and if Young can survive a wrist-slitting, then Soo can survive a fatal knife woundtwice. Wang's crimes. It'll fit, but it's not exactly neat. There are several strong hints for the audience to draw this conclusion before the movie confirms it. When Hee-Sun and Jin-Sung were talking about visiting Soo and bringing Lamb's ear flowers, they were talking about real brother Soo; visiting the river where his ashes were spread. His being a gentleman is one thing I admire too as seen in the bts. I can't buy Jin-sung doing it, I don't see the logic of the threat (did his family get hit by that truck? Dreaming should be kissing already or running while laughing, no real people will talk and if everything was all a dream then why not the director chose to have that scene be with Oh young and Oh soo only and no other people will be part of it and no other thing will included. Amy Harmon is a Wall Street Journal, USA Today, and New York Times bestselling author. Order our What the Wind Knows Study Guide. But the young couple is clearly not a happy one. As far as I'm concerned I"m happy with the ending, the viewer can choose. The setting is Hillsboro, a small rural Tennessee town, during the summer of an unknown year. And throughout the proceedings of the film, we see a woman's descent into madness. Jin-sungs betrayal was so out of character. Apparently shes been a regular at his restaurant and picked up on the sound of his bracelet, and though hed always bring her tea he never showed his face to her. It is a stunning work of fiction interwoven with true historical events, combining the magical and the real. This technique was also used in "Secret Garden" What I am saying is Soo lived daily in Young's heart and mind and isolated world. The surreal film follows a woman's slow descent into madness as she struggles to survive the crushing solitude of the 19th-century frontier lands. Thank you. The vast open spaces, combined with the lack of commercial construction, resulted in small households living alone on huge tracts of land. The average scores when I downloaded this book place it up with The Help and Eleanor Oliphant and that is very misleading imho. There is Balban, the "invader of the weak mind" and "bringer of delusions," Jezebeth, the "seductress," Succorhenoth, the "bringer of jealous thoughts," and Vetis, the "shapeshifter," among others. I did chuckle many times reading this recap. He then calls on the might of Triton, the Grecian God of the Sea and son . There were a lot of "wth" moments in the last few episodes that were left unresolved. Is he alive or just a figment of her memories? : It took some time for me to grasp the numerous characters and the history taking place. I didn't think about it that way when watching the final scene so i believed they both died. , Enhanced typesetting I'm glad I watched, but I wish it had held the awesome all the way through. The title is "Gu Family Book" which is why I expected there's some kind of journey to find said book or even the appearance of it. She wakes up in the world of her grandfathers childhood, where she is reunited with him as a little boy of 6 years old, and after being mistaken for his mother, she gradually uncovers a complex family history that she inadvertently becomes a part of when she falls in love with the boys guardian, Thomas Smith. Overall a beautiful drama with beautiful people. I cant forgive you, she says. It blows harder, annoyed, and tells Santiago to talk to the Hand That Wrote All. I HONESTLY dont know where to start on how much this book meant to me! Reviewed in the United Kingdom on September 1, 2021. Question: I know Heads explained it, however I am still confused, did OS kept folding because if he didn't win he would be dead (being killed by Boss Man) and Boss Man wouldn't be able to get his money back (and OS of course didn't know that Boss Man wanted him dead anyway, regardless of the results)? I hope you like me when you see me after the surgery, he jokes lightly. I'll bet Young cut the short way across her arm too, rather than the long way, which would again be what you would do if you actually wanted to die. Are they both dead and finally meeting in the afterlife? As folks already pointed out, I just don't get why Sec. But I guess in the end, what's important is that they both reconciled and expressed their love to each other and whether they really lived or died didn't matter to me. As a young boy, he was fascinated by Giovanni Caproni planes, which were made by one of Italy's best-known aircraft engineers. There's a gangster figure who seemed really mean, but who is actually a bit of a softie. I'd rate this above "Nice Guy" but below "I Miss You". That scene left me really perplexed because I would have liked to have known what happened (considering how long OS seemed to have been on the ground and he seemed dead. We shouldnt have to go through what a character is feeling in order to understand them if that were the case, how could I understand the plight of second generation chaebol princes or cross-dressing nuns joining an idol group if Ive never been in those shoes? I think the idea of ''the best friend as a traitor'' does make sense in this plot. I didn't think there were many loose ends or plot holes, but the last episode sure makes it seem like there was just because it was like fitting a bunch of things haphazardly in a suitcase in way. Lizzys tale is pieced together through time jumps, simultaneously exploring her sinister past and rapidly deteriorating present. Sun-hee, after a dose of Newfound Optimism, smiles as she claims that Youngs chances are over 50% with that kind of preparedness. Is this another instance of Drama Syndrome, where characters would rather undergo pain and irreparable harm than do something logical?) I did have a much more beautiful hair after my chemo and it takes me only 2 months to grow my hair. Every Amy Harmon book leaves me in awe - completely astonished by the gifts she was endowed with, the feelings she's able to put into language my brain does not possess. But this was seriously a group of really scarred people. Full content visible, double tap to read brief content. It's by no means the worst thing I've ever seen, but it was a letdown - I can live with Young's suicide attempt, but the sudden Drama Fairy handwaving of it is too much. It always leaves room for your interpretation, as shown here by the comments. There are no amount of words to describe this book. I mean, if you want to commit suicide, don't you really slit your wrists (BOTH of them) and get in the water for maximum bleeding? The game amps up as Jin-sungs family loads the truck to move though theyre being watched by a shady-lookin dude. Young goes to a cafe to wait, and we see Soos tree painting hanging on the wall, completed. Amy knew at an early age that writing was something she wanted to do, and she divided her time between writing songs and stories as she grew. And Jinsung and Hee Sung were talking about the memorial for Soo. Powered by WordPress.com VIP. Love is love, no matter which year we live in. There was an error retrieving your Wish Lists. They've seen and heard all that has ever been said or done. Though not implicitly stated, the book could also have something to do with both the womens babies being stillborns as they both have the book during their pregnancy. I thought that you may not like me when you see me. When Young scoffs at this, he asks, Does that mean you like me?. right. I really wanted to like this show, just like I wanted to like Young, and I find them both frustrating and prickly and immensely illogical. This vagued up messy ending was the compromise. Thank you so much <33333333. It was so slow and we were made to think that OS died, because JS didn't seem to do anything to help him and yet, he didn't gut him a 2nd time, which seems like he wanted him to live. FB.init({ }); I dont understand why this conversation cant happen now. He is forever amazing there! I like that about this director/writer pair. Read More: Best Horror Movies of All Time. I dont understand why this conversation cant happen now. I highly recommend reading this book I think Jo In Sung really out did himself here and would watch it again. She learns that a doctor named Thomas Smith raised Eoin after Eoin's parents died during the revolution. Happy waiting for the next trip everyone. xfbml : true, // parse social plugins on this page Oooh, a twist! One possibility is that the reverend exists and is a kind man, and the entity merely disguises itself as the reverend to further torment Lizzy. This would explain how Isaac meets the real reverend while Lizzy is haunted by the spirit in the form of the reverend. well probably what heads meant was that since she underwent a brain surgery, at least part of her hair had to be completely shaved prior to it being performed.. Something that I disagree with Heads here is about the suicidal tendency of OY, in some of her recaps she said that she thinks OY has already get over it. Every time. Sigh! I applaud his professionalism, knowing that this is his first time to have sex scenes. Sean Keane. Although we get to see Lizzy murder Isaac and hence, have a better understanding of it, her murder of Emma is only glimpsed. With Emma, it was her annoying dependence, and with Isaac, it was the revelation that he had had an affair with Emma. Hence, Lizzy had a multitude of reasons to murder the two, and in the end, it was a combination of frustration, anger, fear, and mental anguish that made Lizzy kill them. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. The most important thing being that Soo was still standing at the end-would have hated that he died Young was still alive. Amy Harmon holds more talent in her little finger than most of us could wish to acquire in a lifetime. Outside the room, Sun-hee tells Soo that Moo-chul died after being sick for far too long. I said above, that I hoped for a more straightforward ending bu that I'll take this, too. And if the case hasn't been resolved by June 30 . The ending was definitely real. (And not a moment too soon!). I was so in love with it until that forced kiss and then it basically took a giant swing downhill. One of the main driving forces of Lizzys frustration is her solitude in suffering. When I started watching I already accepted the fact that someone or even all of the lead characters might die. Sans a passing mention of the attempt in a confusing conversation where she simultaneously told Soo that she couldnt forgive him yet she still loved him and wanted to be with him, I failed to see the step between I want to die and I want to try living because now Im extra sure you love me. His love couldnt cure her desire to die just one night earlier, but then by the morning after, his love cures all? Is he a chef and a painter at the end of the show?! And I read and understood the part about OS wanting Boss Man to join in the game so OS can gamble against him and win his money. Also, if they were both in the afterlife, I'm sure Young would get 100% of her sight back. When I slit my wrist, I looked forward to you opening my door instead of feeling scared. But after actually watching it, I'm 100% sure they're both alive. As Anne fell for Thomas, I did too. Same here. Really, why? At first I thought it was some kind of alternate reality where they both died and created it so they (and us viewers) can come into terms with moving on. I like that the characters are happy. His care for Anne shows the type of love every woman should aspire to find. Agreed. And as was mentioned, there is no way Hee-Sun and Jin-Sung could be happy is Soo were really dead. This explains that Oh young has the ability to see but not really clear. I won't try to understand that, just feel like many dramas have this thing with making even some of the foulest people redeemable or sympathetic in cases in which the person has a child or takes care of a child. "If that had been me, Id have taken the knife and gone after Kim.". To be honest, I felt Nice Guy/Innocent Man was more engaging than That Winter, the Wind Blows. He continues on, and Young smiles. That said I think it lost me in episode 12 or 13 with Young's funky character development and the insane troll logic medical stuff. So for a hot second there, I thought that the ending sequence was a dream, in part because of the blurriness of it all and the inherent implausibility of well, everything. I didn't watch this show but I read every recaps on it. Because she chatted and interacted with him. Part romance novel, part historical fiction, What the Wind Knowsimmerses the reader in Ireland circa 1921, alluding to the country's rich cultural legacy of poets and activists. At least Moo-chul's minion seems to have Jin-sung's back. It is also in the mind of the person a VIABLE solution to their problem. However, Lizzy could also have asked about Emmas death just to appear innocent. Five minutes before the ending: WHAT!? No payoff with Denna Ambrose The secret in the Archives his music career the Chandrian his university studies with Fella With sympathy or naming. To me, this drama fizzled out around episode 8. We dont hear or see it, but the look on Jin-sungs face seems to tell us that the truck plowed into his familys car. But in the end, is the choice actually hers to make? At first, it seems pleasant to have others around. It never felt like the characters were tying to be perfect or anything. Follow authors to get new release updates, plus improved recommendations. The only thing negative I could possibly say about What the Wind Knows is that Irish Id read it sooner. I wished they would have saved time there, and showed us what happened after OS was stabbed, instead of letting us speculate on what happened. Jin-sung Why? Soo ekes out, but his next words go to Young: Wait for me. Then he struggles to get up in order to go to her, though he can barely stand. 5 min read. The dedication and loyalty the characters showed to one another was inspiring and beautifully written. Oh soo waited for Oh young to recover (6 months). It didn't disgust me though. Yep! Hence, combined with the ominous booklet that he gives her and his repeated appearances as a violent spirit, the reverend seems to be a very suspicious character indeed and is most likely not a real reverend but a form taken by the evil entity to torment Lizzy. Oh well. She rings it with a smile. You kept a poor young child BLIND so you could in turn create some meaning to your life. Young believes that the only option left for her at this point is to die, but as we've seen before she doesn't really want to (and a lot of people who attempt suicide don't) and is very scared of death. 0.0/10 from 0 users. that he doesnt need it anymore, all while Young stands at her open window, ringing the glass bell as he leaves. it's out of topic but I have to disagree that it's a porn movie, it is sexually graphic yes, but those are used to show how they become lustfully needing each other and to INCREASE TENSION as we go to the part when the deception was caught in the act (we can see their progress of being indifferent to each other up to the point that they're comfortable to do all the positions they want). But time skips are not a panacea, and its a universal truth I really wish dramaland would accept, especially when the end result isnt anything we couldnt have reached without it. Make it confuse and let us choose the ending we want. After hearing this, Lizzy shoots and kills Emma. this reminds me why I'm not a fan of the genre. A single white feather drifts out of the sky and lands on the well-traveled sneaker of Forrest Gump (Tom Hanks), a modest man with a big story to tell. They seemed to have resorted back to their just friends status although Sung was still very much in love with her still. Are they still alive? Whether it really hurt you as much as it hurt me when you were lying. Isnt it hard when you cant look into the eyes of someone you love? Young asks. What the Wind Knows is a masterpiece written by Amy Harmon, an amazing interpretation of events in Ireland during the period of 1916 - 1922. The film's immense runtime (2 hours and 37 minutes) makes it the second longest Marvel . I think that is what the writer ment. How guilty you felt while you loved me. Lawyer Jang finds Secretary Wang in the countryside, where she watches her elderly parents from afar. The art part is just an excuse for porn. In the new film, directed by Charlie McDowell, Nobody is surprised during his break-in when the two owners of a remote estate in Ojai show up unexpectedly. And if you listen, they will tell you all the stories and sing every song. The surreal film follows a womans slow descent into madness as she struggles to survive the crushing solitude of the 19th-century frontier lands. I could feel the discomfort of the clothing, the confusion of being in a new place and time, and see the world as if I was reading in 3D. Despite the fact that she threw the keys blindly into the greenhouse shrubbery the night before, Young emerges into the secret room without a speck of dirt on her. I understand why he wouldnt take Youngs freely-offered money, but it made the entire con seem moot when he could have done this sort of one-gamble-to-rule-them-all from the beginning anyway. It really did feel very Kdrama-like to separate the characters for the sake of separating them? This doesn't change the fact though that this show was sooooo purttty. Ill miss it so much :D. I wanted to clear some things up for you, because I also had my doubts about whether Soo died or not at first. At first I was so upset because I wasn't sure whether Soo was dead or alive, and thought the writer ripped us off with an open-ended ending. He lived like a dog, and died like a dog, she laments, though shes not willing to let Soo comfort her as she tells him that he wont be needed at Moo-chuls cremation. Trending Articles. Don't get me wrong I enjoyed the show but I just feel disappointed because it could have been a great drama. Sex isn't a shameful thing. It is interesting to note that the only person that we see interacting with the reverend is Lizzy. If Oh soo died, the flowers would be placed to a location where he died or to his favorite place or maybe where Oh young and Oh first met. The demons described in the pamphlet could be interpreted as literal entities or merely a list of possible emotional and mental health issues that may be encountered when living in an inhospitable environment in extreme isolation. 2,5, & 6 were my thoughts exactly. And yes, like mentioned above, to show lust and passion. What's with Jin sung and Hee sun talking 'bout bringing flowers to Oh Soo? (hahah). Thank you for the recommendation - watched it, like it! Thomas's worst fear is that Anne will return to her own time. Can you see nothing at all?. This action reflects justice, which is usually represented by two scales, weighing different viewpoints. since you're here, it seems you are doing well. Hee-sun sees Soo off for his big gamble, after which he plans to go to the hospital to see Young. . I always see this movie labeled as "porn", but this is the perfect example of explaining that it isn't. I'm one of those people who would rather have a happy ending than a realistic one. It's what sets this drama apart from the movie version which was a neat package in itself but i felt the drama extended and explored and fleshed out the characters on a deeper level that made me - with the exception of Sec Wang (whatthehell show- she made her blind, i don't care how well she can cook)- connect with the narration as a whole. After the book reading at the cafe, was it only Young's wishful thinking and imagination while she was walking and reminiscing about a dead Soo? Emma is also seen endlessly reciting the book in the final days of her pregnancy. So let me get this straight. None of the motivations made sense after that. Isaac confronts Lizzy about the murder. The hunter knows without a shadow of a doubt that Cas was telling the truth because the Empty wouldn't have claimed him in a moment of true happiness if he weren't. But to me what he did made sense for the character. Amy explained in the most beautiful narrative about the heartbreaking decisions many of these people had to make. I understand almost perfectly the desperation to trust / love someone, feel that if I can end this life - maybe I'll find peace, feel that selfishness because I always have to do and settle things all by myself. Hence, the murder is committed in the spur of the moment. This drama was beautiful and I no doubt loved it but the ending didn't exactly get stupid, it just never explained itself.. Kindle AZW file. :). There were just moments that I wanted to backtrack to check if I missed out anything, but just didn't have the patience to go through the frustrations again. From the very first page all the way to the very end, I was swept up in Amy Harmons beautifully crafted, enchanting story of American-born Anne Gallagher, who travels to Ireland for the first time in her life to fulfill her beloved grandfather Eoins dying wish to have his ashes spread in the lake at his childhood home. It seemingly possesses Isaac's body, leading Lizzy to stab him with a piece of broken glass. Redemption links and eBooks cannot be resold. It was really rushed and that's why I think the logic breaks down. It will probably take how many months before the eyesight will go back to normal condition. After Lewis' death, Dawn decided to get Edith away from Edie and the curse that had taken over the . I totally agree with all your comments, except, I rather liked how they twisted the Jin Sung - Oh Soo loyalty in the end. Get help and learn more about the design. I didn't have a problem with Soo not taking the $$ though! Tags: featured, Jo In-sung, Kim Bum, Song Hye-gyo, That Winter the Wind Blows, Your email address will not be published. Reviewed in the United Kingdom on February 7, 2019. Without knowing exactly how she crossed into this time, she cannot promise she will remain. So the truck didn't run over everyone? Soo falls to the ground with his hand holding his bleeding gut. Then I realized that this drama is just like the character Young: beautiful to look at, given to half-disclosures or sideways feints that make you go into hours of analysis to try and figure it all out. , Page numbers source ISBN They're both crazy beautiful, I want to cry!! The last we see of Lizzy, she is injured but still alive. Maybe he felt like a cornered mouse or panicked. Give as a gift or purchase for a team or group. I like it that some of you are sharing your personal experiences to help us better understand the characters in the drama. but I wondered if it would be rude in a way or something. I've watched it happen in quite a few dramas. If the stories are gone, then the people are gone too. and then she comes and "finds" him meaning her surgery must not have worked out and she died. But then Id be asking for realism, and that is not what this show was selling. But Golden Wind was never meant to be about the best of society either. The following version of the book was used to create this study guide: Harmon, Amy, What the Wind Knows. Her confusion at the beginning of the film as to how Emma got her hands on the gun is also questionable. She calmly observes the ship, amazed that the power of the goddesses was able to rebuild the entire wreckage from the battle with Satyr. If the ending wasn't real then that was s a very elaborate dream with the cafe, watress, the fact that Soo had been for 6 months. The beginning of this drama was so so so good!!! The trailer for No Way Home revealed a bit of how that will happen: Doctor Strange (Benedict Cumberbatch) will seemingly break the multiverse while trying to undo the moment when Peter Parker's. Anne Gallagher grew up enchanted by her grandfathers stories of Ireland. Read instantly on your browser with Kindle for Web. Really? But she didn't, her vision is only recovering, thus the blurry images. As the snowplow is driving her to safety the driver tells her about a policeman in the 1950's that used to kill people on that part of the road and the bodies were never found. I also think it's real because Jin Sung and Hee Sung can't possibly be so cheerful had Jin Sung killed his hyung. While that is the climactic action of the story, the film's final moments give even more context to what came before. Iran-Contra affair. They didn't treat it as a "melodrama disease" with over exaggerated helplessness or what have you. And I like how SHG played OY. I wouldn't be here if it always follows my logic. (Even Wang's redemption arc, though not something I agree with, was well supported within the story -- it didn't come out of nowhere.).
Racing Pigeon Panniers, Republican Policy Committee Chairman Job Description, Leslie Bluhm Net Worth, Dirty Tyler Urban Dictionary, Articles W